From the moment we are old enough to process the idea of ‘us’ versus ‘them,’ humans have shown a remarkable capacity to divide ourselves into categories. Although labels like race, sexuality, or socioeconomic status can help us navigate complex realities, they too often become rigid boundaries that fuel hostility. Throughout history, we have repeatedly sought an enemy—whether it was another tribe, another nation, or simply a group that looks or behaves differently. In a hyperconnected world, these ancient instincts find new life online, where social media amplifies division for the sake of engagement. This article explores how categorizing people into neat boxes—from ‘short kings’ to wealthy elites—reinforces our tribal tendencies and offers pathways to break free from the cycle. By re-examining our biases and embracing nuance, we can begin to see each other as more than the sum of our labels and work toward genuine unity.